| Adrianna | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 85 | Jul 2026 | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Sammy | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 39 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Ruby | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 39 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Sophia | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 33 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Gemma | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 24 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Selene | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 22 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Ciera Garcia | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 22 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Chloe | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 21 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Bella | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 20 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Nikki | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 20 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Victoria | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 20 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Jade | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 17 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Isis / Jenny | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 16 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Emma | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 15 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Kendra | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 13 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Gigi | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 13 | Oct 2023 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Katy | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 11 | Jun 2024 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Gisele Baker / Claudia | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 11 | | (646) 657-7590 | giselebaker8@yahoo.com |
| Catherine | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 10 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Sophie | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 10 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Jordan | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 9 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Jane | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 9 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Asti | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 9 | Jan 2024 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Alexis | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 7 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Moonie | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 6 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Kristi | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 6 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Ariana | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 6 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Layla | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 5 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Nina | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 3 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Marissa | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 3 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Luna | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 3 | Feb 2026 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Sasha Summers | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 3 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Tyler Michaels | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 3 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Nia | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 3 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Kayla (old) | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 3 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Harley | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 31–35 | 2 | Feb 2024 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Mira | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 2 | Feb 2026 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Krystal | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 2 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Erica | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 2 | Jun 2026 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Jane | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 2 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Luna (2023 Only) | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 2 | Nov 2025 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Honey | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | Mar 2024 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Sarah | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 1 | Aug 2024 | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Kristen | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Kayla | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 657-7590 | |
| Ella | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 1 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Maria Claire | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Stephani | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 657-7590 | desiresofnewyork@gmail.com |
| Maya | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 657-7590 | |