| Wren | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 32 | Apr 2023 | (646) 344-1418 | wrenlovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Adriana | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 31–35 | 30 | | (646) 344-1418 | adrianalovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Jenny | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 11 | | (646) 344-1418 | jennylovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Jolie | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 7 | | (212) 448-0211 | jolielovesnyc@gmail.com |
| Heather | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 6 | Aug 2024 | (646) 344-1418 | heatherlovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Camilla | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 4 | Mar 2023 | (646) 344-1418 | |
| Mila | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 3 | Mar 2025 | (646) 344-1419 | madetobemila@proton.me |
| Serena | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 36–40 | 3 | | (646) 344-1418 | serenalovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Avery | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 3 | | (646) 344-1419 | averyxolovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Jolene | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 2 | Oct 2024 | (646) 458-4316 | jolenesensualsanctuary@gmail.com |
| Jessie | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 2 | | (646) 344-1418 | jessielovesnyc@gmail.com |
| Brooke | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 2 | | (646) 344-1418 | brookelovesthiscity@gmail.com |
| Taylor | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 1 | | (646) 344-1418 | taylorlovesthiscity@gmail.com |
| Donna | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | Jul 2023 | (646) 344-1418 | donnalovesthiscity@gmail.com |
| Pamela | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 1 | May 2024 | (646) 344-1418 | pamelalovesthecity@proton.me |
| Kerri | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 344-1419 | kerrilovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Callie | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (212) 213-1495 | callielovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Jojo | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 31–35 | 1 | Aug 2025 | (646) 344-1418 | |
| Sara Love | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 31–35 | 1 | Feb 2026 | (646) 344-1418 | l.sara951010@gmail.com |
| Beth | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 1 | | (646) 344-1418 | bethlovenyc@gmail.com |
| Malinda | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 21–25 | 1 | | (646) 344-1418 | malindalovesthecity@gmail.com |
| Jessica Love | New York City - Manhattan, NY | 26–30 | 1 | | (646) 344-1418 | jessicalovesthecity@gmail.com |